Impact of phosphorus removal agents on precise evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency and improvement strategies

WANG Gang; LI Kuixiao; GAO Yuan; WANG Wei; XU Qi; YU Lan; WU Congcong

doi:10.13205/j.hjgc.202601006

Volume 44 Issue 1

Jan. 2026

Turn off MathJax

Article Contents

Article Navigation > ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING > 2026 > 44(1): 52-60

WANG Gang, LI Kuixiao, GAO Yuan, WANG Wei, XU Qi, YU Lan, WU Congcong. Impact of phosphorus removal agents on precise evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency and improvement strategies[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(1): 52-60. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202601006

Citation:

WANG Gang, LI Kuixiao, GAO Yuan, WANG Wei, XU Qi, YU Lan, WU Congcong. Impact of phosphorus removal agents on precise evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency and improvement strategies[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(1): 52-60. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202601006

Citation:

WANG Gang, LI Kuixiao, GAO Yuan, WANG Wei, XU Qi, YU Lan, WU Congcong. Impact of phosphorus removal agents on precise evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency and improvement strategies[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(1): 52-60. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202601006

PDF( 1165 KB)

Impact of phosphorus removal agents on precise evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency and improvement strategies

doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202601006

WANG Gang^1,2,
LI Kuixiao^{1,2
,
,},
GAO Yuan¹,
WANG Wei^1,2,
XU Qi^1,2,
YU Lan¹,
WU Congcong^1,2

1. Beijing Drainage Group Co., Ltd., Beijing 100022, China;
2. Beijing Municipal Sewage Resource Engineering Technology Research Center, Beijing 100124, China

Received Date: 2024-08-29
Available Online: 2026-02-26
Publish Date: 2026-01-22

Abstract

Abstract

In the operation of wastewater treatment plants （WWTPs）， a rather critical issue has emerged where the biological phosphorus removal efficiency is often unable to be precisely characterized because of the influence of the residual chemical phosphorus removal agents in the system， which in turn gives rise to the problem that excessive amounts of phosphorus removal agents are dosed， not only causing waste of resources but also potentially disrupting the normal operation and performance of the WWTPs. In this paper， a combined approach integrating bench-scale tests in a laboratory setting and on-site tests mirroring the actual operation conditions of WWTPs was adopted to clearly expound the impact of chemical phosphorus removal agents on the evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency. When constructing the evaluation system for biological phosphorus removal efficiency， several key characterization indicators such as polyphosphate which is of great importance in the processes of phosphorus storage and release within the biological systems of WWTPs， polyphosphate-accumulating organisms （PAOs） which are the core microorganisms in phosphorus accumulation， and poly-β-hydroxybutyrate （PHB）， an essential metabolite closely related to the energy metabolism and phosphorus removal， were chosen， and integrated with the analytic hierarchy process（AHP） to establish a brand-new and comprehensive evaluation system for biological phosphorus removal efficiency. Subsequently， the evaluation of biological phosphorus removal efficiency was carried out for three WWTPs in Beijing with different treatment processes. Based on the evaluation results， targeted improvement strategies were put forward. The results showed that the residues of chemical phosphorus removal agents remaining in the system can seriously affect the accuracy of the evaluation results of biological phosphorus removal efficiency. In the case of WWTP A， the error exceeded 40%. This led to the inability to accurately dose phosphorus removal agents， thereby greatly interfering with the operation and regulation of the WWTP. Fortunately， the newly developed evaluation method can effectively eliminate the influence and obtain the accurate proportion of biological phosphorus removal in the wastewater treatment process， with an evaluation accuracy higher than 95%. When conducting the evaluation of biological phosphorus removal in WWTPs， it is recommended to mainly focus on detecting the changes in sludge polyphosphate， and take the detection results of the abundance of PAOs and PHB as supplementary information. By combining these three evaluation indicators and dynamically adjusting the operating parameters of the biological tank in the WWTP， and the dosing amount of phosphorus removal agents， the strengthening of biological phosphorus removal and the accurate dosing of phosphorus removal agents can be achieved， thus improving the overall operation efficiency and environmental protection level of the WWTP.
- phosphorus removal agents,
- biological phosphorus removal,
- analytic hierarchy process （AHP）,
- evaluation system,
- improvement strategies

FullText(HTML)

References(32)

References

[1]	WANG G，LI K X，SHI Y L，et al. Effect law of sludge depths variation in primary sedimentation tank on biological phosphorus removal[J]. Water Purification Technology，2022，41（9）：67-71. 王刚，李魁晓，时玉龙，等. 初沉池泥位变化对生物除磷影响规律[J]. 净水技术，2022，41（9）：67-71.
[2]	WANG G，LI K X，XU Q，et al. Study on the coupling effect of three kinds of phosphorus removal in municipal sewage treatment plant[J]. Environmental Pollution& Control，2022，44（11）：1457-1461. 王刚，李魁晓，许骐，等. 城镇污水处理厂3种除磷方式耦合除磷效果研究[J]. 环境污染与防治，2022，44（11）：1457-1461.
[3]	LIU Z X. A new breakthrough in the theory and practice of biological phosphorus removal：from mainstream EBPR to side-stream EBPR[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2018，34（24）：19-25. 刘智晓. 生物除磷理论及实践新突破：从主流EBPR到侧流EBPR[J]. 中国给水排水，2018，34（24）：19-25.
[4]	YI J，WANG J H，WANG X F，et al. Influencing factors of biological phosphorous removal in sewage treatment[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2007，1（4）：6-11. 尹军，王建辉，王雪峰，等. 污水生物除磷若干影响因素分析[J]. 环境工程学报，2007，1（4）：6-11.
[5]	ZHANG C，GUISASOLA A，BAEZA J A. A review on the integration of mainstream P-recovery strategies with enhanced biological phosphorus removal[J]. Water Research，2022，212：118102.
[6]	LU X，DUAN H，OEHMEN A. Achieving combined biological short-cut nitrogen and phosphorus removal in a one sludge system with side-stream sludge treatment[J]. Water Research，2021，203：117563.
[7]	LI B F. Research on biological phosphorus removal assisted by chemical phosphorus removal in Longwangzui wastewater treatment plant[D]. Wuhan：Wuhan University of Technology，2013. 李博夫. 龙王嘴污水处理厂生物辅以化学除磷研究[D]. 武汉：武汉理工大学，2013.
[8]	LIU L. Study on the phosphorus release of the returning sludge and the effects of sludge side-stream assisted with chemical phosphorus removal on mainstream biological system[D]. Xi'an：Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology，2018. 刘伦. 富含磷污泥回流过程中磷的释出及侧流化学脱除污泥中磷对主流生物系统的影响研究[D]. 西安：西安建筑科技大学，2018.
[9]	CHEN Y S. The effect on activated sludge of chemical coagulants applied in synchronization dephosphorization[J]. Journal of Environmental Protection，2013，04（12）：1423-1427.
[10]	LI K X，WANG G，LIU L C，et al. A measuring device for sludge phosphorus storage capacity：CN216926670U[P]. 2022-7-8. 李魁晓，王刚，刘立超，等. 一种污泥磷容量的检测装置：CN216926670U[P]. 2022-7-8.
[11]	WANG G，LI K X，JIANG D W，et al. Research on phosphorus removal efficiency improvement control technology of sewage treatment plant based on phosphorus storage capacity[J]. Environmental Pollution& Control，2024，46（4）：497-501. 王刚，李魁晓，姜大伟，等. 基于磷容量的污水处理厂除磷效能提升控制技术研究[J]. 环境污染与防治，2024，46（4）：497-501.
[12]	REN Y，WEI C H. Biological phosphorus removal efficiency and structural analysis of synthetic PHAs by five different carbon sources[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2006，22（S1）：327-332. 任源，韦朝海. 不同碳源的生物除磷效率及合成PHAs结构分析[J]. 中国给水排水，2006，22（增刊1）：327-332.
[13]	LONG X Y，FANG Z D，TANG R，et al. Roles of extracellular polymer substances in biological dephosphorization[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae，2012，32（4）：784-789. 龙向宇，方振东，唐然，等. 胞外聚合物在生物除磷中作用的研究[J]. 环境科学学报，2012，32（4）：784-789.
[14]	SUN Y L，ZHENG X C，LIU Z J，et al. Impact of simultaneous chemical phosphorous removal on biological phosphorous removal in WWTPs[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2015，31（19）：68-71. 孙永利，郑兴灿，刘振江，等. 城镇污水厂化学协同除磷对生物除磷的影响[J]. 中国给水排水，2015，31（19）：68-71.
[15]	HOU H J，ZHOU Q，QIU Z F，et al. Study on cooperative phosphorus removal by biological and chemical processes[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Engineering，2006，7（2）：50-52. 侯红娟，周琪，邱兆富，等. 生物化学协同除磷研究[J]. 环境工程学报，2006，7（2）：50-52.
[16]	SEPA. Water and wastewater monitoring and analysis methods[M]. 4th Ed. Beijing：China Environmental Science Press，2002. 国家环境保护总局. 水和废水监测分析方法[M]. 4版. 中国环境科学出版社，2002.
[17]	FAN Z，ZENG W，WANG B，et al. Analysis of microbial community in a continuous flow process at gene and transcription level to enhance biological nutrients removal from municipal wastewater[J]. Bioresource Technology，2019，286：121374.
[18]	YOU Y，PENG Y Z，WANG S Y，et al. Optimization of intracellular polymer analysis for enhanced biological phosphorous removal system[J]. Journal of Harbin Institute of Technology，2010，42（2）：207-211. 由阳，彭永臻，王淑莹，等. 强化生物除磷系统胞内聚合物测定方法优化[J]. 哈尔滨工业大学学报，2010，42（2）：207-211.
[19]	HUPFER M，GLÖSS S，SCHMIEDER P. Methods for detection and quantification of polyphosphate and polyphosphate-accumulating microorganisms in aquatic sediments[J]. International Review of Hydrobiology，2010，93（1）：1-30.
[20]	JIA Q，XIONG H，WANG H. Production of polyhydroxyalkanoates（PHA）by bacterial consortium from excess sludge fermentation liquid at laboratory and pilot scales[J]. Bioresource Technology，2014，171：159-167.
[21]	ZHOU M J，JI S L，CUI D H，et al. Quick screening of polyphosphate-accumulating strains and its characteristics[J]. China Environmental Science，2012，32（10）：1838-1844. 周明璟，纪树兰，崔丹红，等. 厌氧/好氧交替快速筛选聚磷菌及其生理特性的研究[J]. 中国环境科学，2012，32（10）：1838-1844.
[22]	KANG H，WANG X H，LI N，et al. Characterization of phosphate-accumulating organisms in starting-up EBPR by FISH analysis[J]. Environmental Science，2009，30（1）：80-84. 亢涵，王秀蘅，李楠，等. 生物除磷系统启动期聚磷菌的FISH原位分析与聚磷特性[J]. 环境科学，2009，30（1）：80-84.
[23]	JANSSEN P.M.J.； MEINEMA K.； VAN DER ROEST H.F.. Biological phosphorus removal manual for design and operation[J]. Water Environment& Technology，2006.
[24]	WANG G，LI K X，WANG W，et al. Effects of phosphorus form and suspended solids content on phosphorus concentration in reclaimed water[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2023，39（11）：109-114. 王刚，李魁晓，王慰，等. 磷元素形态及悬浮物含量对再生水磷浓度的影响[J]. 中国给水排水，2023，39（11）：109-114.
[25]	SUN Y P. Screening of phosphorus-accumulating organisms and study of polyphosphate promote the PHB accumulation[D]. Harbin：Northeast Forestry University，2009. 孙艺萍. 聚磷菌的筛选及其体内聚磷酸盐推动PHB积累的研究[D]. 哈尔滨：东北林业大学，2009.
[26]	REN H T. Effects of environmental factors on phosphorus release and phosphorus uptake by phosphorus accumulating bacteria and mechanism of excessive phosphorus accumulation[D]. Xi'an：Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology，2017. 任皓甜. 环境因素对聚磷菌释磷和摄磷的影响及超量聚磷机理研究[D]. 西安：西安建筑科技大学，2017.
[27]	PAN Y，YU M X，HUANG Y，et al. Phosphorus removal characteristics of sludge transfer sequencing batch reactor（SBR）process[J]. Environmental Chemistry，2013，32（2）：275-280. 潘杨，俞苗新，黄勇，等. 污泥转移序批式间歇活性污泥法（SBR）工艺除磷特性[J]. 环境化学，2013，32（2）：275-280.
[28]	TIAN S Y，WANG J F，YANG R，et al. Study on PHB and polyphosphate under anaerobic conditions and their biochemical mechanisms[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2000，16（7）：5-7. 田淑媛王景峰，杨睿，等. 厌氧下的PHB和聚磷酸盐及其生化机理研究[J]. 中国给水排水，2000，16（7）：5-7.
[29]	CHEN X，DAI X C，HUANG M S，et al. Monitoring and analysis of PHB and OUR in the A²/O System[J]. Industrial Water Treatment，2009，29（9）：77-80. 陈曦，戴兴春，黄民生，等. A²/O系统PHB和OUR监测及其分析研究[J]. 工业水处理，2009，29（9）：77-80.
[30]	GUO Z Y，ZHAO X L，LI J C，et al. Study on selection of phosphorus removal scheme based on analytic hierarchy process[J]. Journal of Qingdao University of Technology，2021，42（1）：86-90. 郭众一，赵晓莉，李金成，等. 基于层次分析法的化学除磷方案选择研究[J]. 青岛理工大学学报，2021，42（1）：86-90.
[31]	HU T J，CHEN W P，ZENG G M，et al. The process of wastewater treatment in Zhuzhou Xiawan sewage treatment plant was optimized by using analytic hierarchy process[J]. Environmental Engineering，2000，18（1）：61-63. 胡天觉，陈维平，曾光明，等. 运用层次分析法对株洲霞湾污水处理厂污水处理工艺方案择优[J]. 环境工程，2000，18（1）：61-63.
[32]	ZHANG Y Q. Application of analytic hierarchy process in comprehensive evaluation of water purification treatment technologies[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2015，31（3）：58-61. 张轶群. 层次分析法在净水处理技术综合评价中的应用[J]. 中国给水排水，2015，31（3）：58-61.