Recent advances of membrane fouling characterization in membrane based wastewater treatment

TIAN Duanyun; YANG Xiaohuan; HAO Litu; LEI Zhen; CHEN Rong

doi:10.13205/j.hjgc.202602001

Volume 44 Issue 2

Feb. 2026

Turn off MathJax

Article Contents

Article Navigation > ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING > 2026 > 44(2): 1-14

TIAN Duanyun, YANG Xiaohuan, HAO Litu, LEI Zhen, CHEN Rong. Recent advances of membrane fouling characterization in membrane based wastewater treatment[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(2): 1-14. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202602001

Citation:

TIAN Duanyun, YANG Xiaohuan, HAO Litu, LEI Zhen, CHEN Rong. Recent advances of membrane fouling characterization in membrane based wastewater treatment[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(2): 1-14. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202602001

Citation:

PDF( 2191 KB)

Recent advances of membrane fouling characterization in membrane based wastewater treatment

doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202602001

TIAN Duanyun^1,2,
YANG Xiaohuan^1,2,
HAO Litu^1,2,
LEI Zhen^{1,2
,
,},
CHEN Rong^1,2

1. Key Laboratory of Northwest China Water Resources and Environment Ecology, Ministry of Education, Xi'an 710055, China;
2. Shaanxi Provincial Key Laboratory of Environmental Engineering, School of Environmental and Municipal Engineering, Xi'an University of Architecture and Technology, Xi'an 710055, China

Received Date: 2025-07-21
Available Online: 2026-04-11
Publish Date: 2026-02-01

Abstract

Abstract

Membrane technology has become an important technology in the water treatment industry due to its advantages of high separation efficiency， stable performance and good effluent quality. However， membrane fouling—leading to membrane flux decline， shortened operational cycles， and increased treatment costs—remains a critical bottleneck hindering the further development of this technology. To accurately analyze pollutant composition， elucidate the spatial structural characteristics of fouling layers， dynamically monitor pollution evolution patterns， and clarify underlying mechanisms， the scientific selection and application of membrane fouling characterization methods are essential. This review focuses on membrane fouling issues in membrane-based wastewater treatment. Based on the spatiotemporal resolution of characterization techniques， fouling characterization methods are classified into three categories： ex-situ characterization， in-situ characterization， and real-time monitoring. The principles， technical advantages， and application limitations of each method are systematically reviewed and compared. By discussing applicable scenarios for each method， this work provides insights to deepen the mechanistic understanding of membrane fouling and advance the development of fouling control strategies.
- membrane fouling,
- characterization method,
- fouling process,
- in-situ characterization,
- real-time monitoring

FullText(HTML)

References(120)

References

[1]	BORETTI A，ROSA L. Reassessing the projections of the World Water Development Report［J］. NPJ Clean Water，2019，2（1）:6.
[2]	ZHAO X，ZHANG R，LIU Y，et al. Antifouling membrane surface construction:chemistry plays a critical role［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2018，551:145-171.
[3]	LI X，CHOU S，WANG R，et al. Nature gives the best solution for desalination:aquaporin-based hollow fiber composite membrane with superior performance［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2015，494:68-77.
[4]	ZHAO S，LIAO Z，FANE A，et al. Engineering antifouling reverse osmosis membranes:a review［J］. Desalination，2021，499:110311.
[5]	ZHANG L，TIAN X Y，SHI L W，et al. Research status of MBR membrane pollution prevention and control strategies［J］. Environmental Engineering，2023，41（12）:174-178. 张雷，田雪咏，史立伟，等. MBR 膜污染防治策略研究现状［J］. 环境工程，2023，41（12）:174-178.
[6]	LI X，LEE H S，WANG Z，et al. State-of-the-art management technologies of dissolved methane in anaerobically-treated low-strength wastewaters:a review［J］. Water Research，2021，200:117941.
[7]	LI X，DUTTA A，SAHA S，et al. Recovery of dissolved methane from anaerobically treated food waste leachate using solvent-based membrane contactor［J］. Water Research，2020，175:115719.
[8]	WANG Y N，WEI J，SHE Q H，et al. Microscopic characterization of FO/PRO membranes:a comparative study of CLSM，TEM and SEM［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2012，46（18）:9995-10003.
[9]	DING J，XIAO H，HUANG X，et al. Application of heat-activated peroxydisulfate process for the chemical cleaning of fouled ultrafiltration membranes［J］. Chinese Chemical Letters，2023，34（10）:108316.
[10]	TAN Z，CHEN S，PENG X，et al. Polyamide membranes with nanoscale Turing structures for water purification［J］. Science，2018，360（6388）:518-521.
[11]	AHSANI M，OGHYANOUS F A，MEYER J，et al. PVDF membranes modified with diblock copolymer PEO-b-PMMA as additive:effects of copolymer and barrier pore size on filtration performance and fouling in a membrane bioreactor［J］. Chemical Engineering Research and Design，2022，184:678-691.
[12]	YANG J，LI X，WEI M，et al. Base-activated persulfate strategy for ceramic membrane cleaning after treatment of natural surface water［J］. Chemical Engineering Research and Design，2023，194:245-255.
[13]	LIN D，LAI C，WANG X，et al. Enhanced membrane fouling by microplastics during nanofiltration of secondary effluent considering secretion，interaction and deposition of extracellular polymeric substances［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2024，906:167110.
[14]	ALPIGER S B，SOLET C，DANG T T，et al. Ultrafiltration of rapeseed protein concentrate:effect of pectinase treatment on membrane fouling［J］. Foods，2024，13（15）:2423.
[15]	MUSTAFA Z Z，MURDOCK A T，XIE Z，et al. Impact of membrane characteristics and chemical ageing on algal protein fouling behaviour of ultrafiltration membranes［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2025，354:128481.
[16]	YURTSEVER A，BASARAN E，UCAR D. Process optimization and filtration performance of an anaerobic dynamic membrane bioreactor treating textile wastewaters［J］. Journal of Environmental Management，2020，273:111114.
[17]	QIAO Y，HAN X，CHEN F，et al. Control behavior of pretreatment on ceramic membrane fouling caused by different organic substances［J］. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering，2024，12（1）:111884.
[18]	NAM S N，JO K，KIM S，et al. Evaluation of secondary effluent organic matter removal by an in-series forward osmosis-ultrafiltration hybrid process using parallel factor analysis with self-organizing maps［J］. Chemical Engineering Journal，2023，464:142640.
[19]	QI J，ZHOU Q，HUANG D，et al. Construction of synthetic anti-fouling consortia:fouling control effects and polysaccharide degradation mechanisms［J］. Microbial Cell Factories，2023，22（1）:14.
[20]	FENG L，MU H，GAO Z，et al. Comprehensive insights into the impact of magnetic biochar on protein hydrolysis in sludge anaerobic digestion:protein structures，microbial activities and syntrophic metabolisms［J］. Water Research，2024，260:121963.
[21]	WANG J，LIU Q，XU L，et al. Impacts of water hardness on coagulation-UF-NF process using aluminum salts［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2023，314:123611.
[22]	TAJIK M，PEYRAVI M，LASHKARBOLOOKI M. Modified PES membrane by imidazolium-based ionic liquid to investigate fouling by oily foulant:theoretical and experimental study［J］. Journal of Water Process Engineering，2024，60:105086.
[23]	SHAPOURI L，MASOUMI S，DADGAR N，et al. Preparation，characterization，and fouling analysis of PVC/ND-PEG ultrafiltration membranes for whey separation［J］. Diamond and Related Materials，2024，142:110776.
[24]	SHAPOURI L，MASOUMI S，DADGAR N，et al. Polyethersulfone（PES）ultrafiltration membranes modified with Mg–Al-layered double hydroxide nanoparticles for treatment of petroleum refinery wastewater［J］. Iranian Polymer Journal，2024，33（2）:143-155.
[25]	GOYAT R，SINGH J，UMAR A，et al. Synthesis and characterization of nanocomposite based polymeric membrane（PES/PVP/GO-TiO₂）and performance evaluation for the removal of various antibiotics（amoxicillin，azithromycin& ciprofloxacin）from aqueous solution［J］. Chemosphere，2024，353:141542.
[26]	ROBERGE H，MOREAU P，COUALLIER E，et al. Determination of the key structural factors affecting permeability and selectivity of PAN and PES polymeric filtration membranes using 3D FIB/SEM［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，653:120530.
[27]	CAI Y-H，BURKHARDT C J，SCHÄFER A I. Renewable energy powered membrane technology:impact of osmotic backwash on organic fouling during solar irradiance fluctuation［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，647:120286.
[28]	MARSHALL A G，NEIKIRK K，STEPHENS D C，et al. Serial block face-scanning electron microscopy as a burgeoning technology［J］. Advanced Biology，2023，7（8）:2300139.
[29]	LEAPMAN R D，CRUZ D R，PALUMBO D J，et al. Comparison of ultrastructure determined by serial block face sem and focused ion beam SEM from blood platelets and thrombi［J］. Microscopy and Microanalysis，2022，28（S1）:1472-1474.
[30]	YAN H，WANG Y，ZHANG J，et al. Rice root hair phenotypes imaged by cryo-SEM［J］. Bio-protocol，2021，11（11）:e4037.
[31]	ROBERGE H，MOREAU P，COUALLIER E，et al. Lipids and proteins differentiation in membrane fouling using heavy metal staining and electron microscopy at cryogenic temperatures［J］. Microscopy and Microanalysis，2023，29（6）:2090-2098.
[32]	BISWAS P，BANDYOPADHYAYA R. Synergistic antibacterial activity of a combination of silver and copper nanoparticle impregnated activated carbon for water disinfection［J］. Environmental Science:Nano，2017，4（12）:2405-2417.
[33]	ASLAM M，WICAKSANA F，FARID M，et al. Mitigation of membrane fouling by whey protein via water hammer［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，642:119967.
[34]	KANG Y，ZHENG S，FINNERTY C，et al. Regenerable polyelectrolyte membrane for ultimate fouling control in forward osmosis［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2017，51（6）:3242-3249.
[35]	LI P H，LINDSEY L F，JANUSZEWSKI M，et al. Automated reconstruction of a serial-section EM drosophila brain with flood-Filling networks and local realignment［J］. Microscopy and Microanalysis，2019，25（S2）:1364-1365.
[36]	ZHAO J，YU X，SHENTU X，et al. The application and development of electron microscopy for three-dimensional reconstruction in life science:a review［J］. Cell and Tissue Research，2024，396（1）:1-18.
[37]	HE M，ZHOU Y，NIE S，et al. Synthesis of amphiphilic copolymers containing ciprofloxacin and amine groups and their antimicrobial performances as revealed by confocal laser-scanning microscopy and atomic-force microscopy［J］. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry，2018，66（31）:8406-8414.
[38]	KASTL A，BOGLER A，SPINNLER M，et al. Impact of hydrodynamics on the first stages of biofilm formation in forward osmosis with spacers［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2020，54（8）:5279-5287.
[39]	CHENG L，SHAIKH A R，FANG L-F，et al. Fouling-resistant and self-cleaning aliphatic polyketone membrane for sustainable oil-water emulsion separation［J］. ACS Applied Materials& Interfaces，2018，10（51）:44880-44889.
[40]	DARVIN M E. Optical methods for non-invasive determination of skin penetration:current trends，advances，possibilities，prospects，and translation into in vivo human studies［J］. Pharmaceutics，2023，15（9）:2272.
[41]	TOW E W，RAD B，KOSTECKI R. Biofouling of filtration membranes in wastewater reuse:in situ visualization with confocal laser scanning microscopy［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，644:120021.
[42]	LI Y，ZHAO Y J，WANG M，et al. Enhanced anti-fouling and selective performance of GO-modified nanofiltration membranes for lithium extraction from salt lake brine［J］. Chemical Engineering Journal，2024，499:156269.
[43]	YOU X，SHEN L，ZHAO Y，et al. Quantifying interfacial interactions for improved membrane antifouling:a novel approach using triangulation and surface element integration method［J］. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science，2023，650:775-783.
[44]	FLECHSIG H，ANDO T. Protein dynamics by the combination of high-speed AFM and computational modeling［J］. Current Opinion in Structural Biology，2023，80:102591.
[45]	GU S，HAO M，PAN P，et al. A novel PRC signal drift reduction method for new developed SEM-based nanoindentation/nanoscratch instrument integrated with AFM［J］. Precision Engineering，2021，69:8-18.
[46]	SALDI G D，CAUSSERAND C，SCHOTT J. Dolomite dissolution mechanisms at acidic pH:new insights from high resolution pH-stat and mixed-flow reactor experiments associated to AFM and TEM observations［J］. Chemical Geology，2021，584:120521.
[47]	KAHLE E R，PATEL N，SREENIVASAPPA H B，et al. Targeting cell-matrix interface mechanobiology by integrating AFM with fluorescence microscopy［J］. Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology，2022，176:67-81.
[48]	PURA J L，SALVO-COMINO C，GARCÍA-CABEZóN C，et al. Concurrent study of the electrochemical response and the surface alterations of silver nanowire modified electrodes by means of EC-AFM. The role of electrode/nanomaterial interaction［J］. Surfaces and Interfaces，2023，38:102792.
[49]	WANG Y，ZHENG X，WANG Z，et al. Effects of—COOH and—NH₂ on adsorptive polysaccharide fouling under varying pH conditions:contributing factors and underlying mechanisms［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2021，621:118933.
[50]	WEI M，ZHANG Y，WANG Y，et al. Employing atomic force microscopy（AFM）for microscale investigation of interfaces and interactions in membrane fouling processes:new perspectives and prospects［J］. Membranes，2024，14（2）:35.
[51]	WANG Y，ZHENG X，LI D，et al. Comparison of membrane fouling induced by protein，polysaccharide and humic acid under sodium and calcium ionic conditions［J］. Desalination，2023，548:116236.
[52]	ZHU R，DIAZ A J，SHEN Y，et al. Mechanism of humic acid fouling in a photocatalytic membrane system［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2018，563:531-540.
[53]	RATHINAM K，ABRAHAM S，OREN Y，et al. Surface-induced silica scaling during brackish water desalination:the role of surface charge and specific chemical groups［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2019，53（9）:5202-5211.
[54]	ZHU X Z，WANG L F，ZHANG F，et al. Combined fouling of forward osmosis membrane by alginate and TiO₂ nanoparticles and fouling mitigation mechanisms［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2021，622:119003.
[55]	ZHOU M，SANDSTRöM H，BELIOKA M-P，et al. Investigation of the cohesive strength of membrane fouling layers formed during cross-flow microfiltration:the effects of pH adjustment on the properties and fouling characteristics of microcrystalline cellulose［J］. Chemical Engineering Research and Design，2019，149:52-64.
[56]	BINAHMED S，HOZALSKI R M，ROMERO V C S. Feed temperature effects on organic fouling of reverse osmosis membranes:competition of interfacial and transport properties［J］. ACS ES&T Engineering，2021，1（3）:591-602.
[57]	SIEBDRATH N，SKIBINSKI B，ABRAHAM S，et al. Impact of pretreatment on RO membrane organic fouling:composition and adhesion of tertiary wastewater effluent organic matter［J］. Environmental Science:Water Research& Technology，2021，7（4）:775-788.
[58]	BOO C，HONG S，ELIMELECH M. Relating organic fouling in membrane distillation to intermolecular adhesion forces and interfacial surface energies［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2018，52（24）:14198-14207.
[59]	ZHANG J，ZENG H. Intermolecular and Surface Interactions in Engineering Processes［J］. Engineering，2021，7（1）:63-83.
[60]	XIANG L，ZHU S，LI M，et al. Probing fouling mechanism of naphthenic acids on forward osmosis polymer membranes in oil sands process water treatment［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2019，576:161-170.
[61]	LU Q，HUANG J，MAAN O，et al. Probing molecular interaction mechanisms of organic fouling on polyamide membrane using a surface forces apparatus:Implication for wastewater treatment［J］. Science of the Total Environment，2018，622-623:644-654.
[62]	FAIVRE J，SHRESTHA B R，BURDYNSKA J，et al. Wear protection without surface modification using a synergistic mixture of molecular brushes and linear polymers［J］. ACS Nano，2017，11（2）:1762-1769.
[63]	PARK S，CHOI S，LEE Y K，et al. Cation-π Interactions contribute to hydrophobic humic acid removal for the control of hydraulically irreversible membrane fouling［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2023，57（9）:3853-3863.
[64]	SKODA M W A，CONZELMANN N F，FRIES M R，et al. Switchable β-lactoglobulin（BLG）adsorption on protein resistant oligo（ethylene glycol）（OEG）self-assembled monolayers（SAMs）［J］. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science，2022，606:1673-1683.
[65]	HODGES C S，HARBOTTLE D，BIGGS S. Investigating adsorbing viscoelastic fluids using the quartz crystal microbalance［J］. ACS Omega，2020，5（35）:22081-22090.
[66]	DENG H，REN H，FAN J，et al. Membrane fouling mitigation by coagulation and electrostatic repulsion using an electro-AnMBR in kitchen wastewater treatment［J］. Water Research，2022，222:118883.
[67]	ESKHAN A，ALQASAS N，JOHNSON D. Interaction mechanisms and predictions of the biofouling of polymer films:a combined atomic force microscopy and quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring study［J］. Langmuir，2023，39（18）:6592-6612.
[68]	GOU M，ZHAO Y，LI B，et al. Scaling behavior of cation exchange membrane induced by Ca²⁺ during the electrodialysis for enriching lithium-containing solutions［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2025，713:123283.
[69]	CONWAY K M，URBAN J J，MI B. Sacrificial MoS₂-Polyelectrolyte membranes for fouling control in nanofiltration and reverse osmosis［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2025，713:123251.
[70]	FENG Z，FENG X，LU X. Bioinspired N-oxide-based zwitterionic polymer brushes for robust fouling-resistant surfaces［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2023，57（18）:7298-7308.
[71]	DILXAT D，HABIBUL N，SHENG G P，et al. High performance polyvinylidene fluoride membrane functionalized with poly（ionic liquid）brushes for dual resistance to organic and biological fouling［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2023，312:123415.
[72]	ZHANG C，BAO Q，WU H，et al. Impact of polysaccharide and protein interactions on membrane fouling:particle deposition and layer formation［J］. Chemosphere，2022，296:135710.
[73]	BELLASSAI N，MARTI A，SPOTO G，et al. Low-fouling，mixed-charge poly-l-lysine polymers with anionic oligopeptide side-chains［J］. Journal of Materials Chemistry B，2018，6（46）:7662-7673.
[74]	WANG J，LIU Q，LI X，et al. In-situ monitoring AHL-mediated quorum-sensing regulation of the initial phase of wastewater biofilm formation［J］. Environment International，2020，135:105409.
[75]	LAI L，SIM L N，KRANTZ W B，et al. Characterization of colloidal fouling in forward osmosis via ultrasonic time-（UTDR）and frequency-domain reflectometry（UFDR）［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2020，602:118913.
[76]	LI J，LIU J，YANG T，et al. Quantitative study of the effect of electromagnetic field on scale deposition on nanofiltration membranes via UTDR［J］. Water Research，2007，41（20）:4595-4610.
[77]	XU X，LI J，LI H，et al. Non-invasive monitoring of fouling in hollow fiber membrane via UTDR［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2009，326（1/2）:103-110.
[78]	LI X，LI J，WANG J，et al. In situ investigation of fouling behavior in submerged hollow fiber membrane module under sub-critical flux operation via ultrasonic time domain reflectometry［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2012，411-412:137-145.
[79]	MO J，YANG Y，LI X，et al. Conquering surfactant-induced partial wetting of commercial membrane in membrane distillation through in-situ water flushing［J］. Journal of Membrane Science Letters，2024，4（2）:100082.
[80]	IOANNOU D，SAPALIDIS A，GOGOLIDES E. White Light Reflectance Spectroscopy as a novel and noninvasive method for in situ wetting monitoring in membrane distillation［J］. Desalination，2024，574:117242.
[81]	WAN H，LI X，LUO Y，et al. Early monitoring of pore wetting in membrane distillation using ultrasonic time-domain reflectometry（UTDR）［J］. Water Research，2023，240:119683.
[82]	MO J，LI X，YANG Z. Nanofiber membranes immobilized with in-situ grown nanoparticles for enhanced wetting resistance in direct contact membrane distillation［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2024，345:126810.
[83]	HUANG T Y，SEO J，CHONG T H. Characterization of membrane wetting phenomenon by ionic liquid via ultrasonic time-domain reflectometry（UTDR）［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，641:119949.
[84]	SIM S T V，SUWARNO S R，CHONG T H，et al. Monitoring membrane biofouling via ultrasonic time-domain reflectometry enhanced by silica dosing［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2013，428/429:24-37.
[85]	CHENG Z，MENG X，WANG Y，et al. Insights of membrane fouling under scale inhibitor synergistic condition monitored by ultrasonic phased array:Fouling spatial and density characteristics［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2024，699:122670.
[86]	TIAN J，TRINH T A，KALYAN M N，et al. In-situ monitoring of oil emulsion fouling in ultrafiltration via electrical impedance spectroscopy（EIS）:Influence of surfactant［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2020，616:118512.
[87]	TANUDJAJA H J，NG A Q Q，CHEW J W. Mechanistic insights into the membrane fouling mechanism during ultrafiltration of high-concentration proteins via in-situ electrical impedance spectroscopy（EIS）［J］. Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry，2022，106:429-448.
[88]	LIU J，YU Y，CHEN S，et al. Electrochemical analysis of ion-exchange membranes fouling during electrodialysis treatment of real shale gas flowback water［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2024，706:122954.
[89]	TRAN M L，FU C C，WU M H，et al. Experimental verification on real-time fouling analysis in crossflow UF of protein solutions by electrical impedance spectroscopy［J］. Journal of the Taiwan Institute of Chemical Engineers，2022，133:104197.
[90]	WANG L，WU Y，YOU Z，et al. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy（EIS）reveals the role of microbial fuel cell-ceramic membrane bioreactor（MFC-CMBR）:electricity utilization and membrane fouling［J］. Water Research，2022，222:118854.
[91]	GUO M，JIA H，GAO F，et al. Concentration polarization and membrane fouling characteristics in ultrafiltration based on electrical impedance analysis:synergistic or translational？［J］. Desalination，2025，611:118922.
[92]	ZHANG N，HALALI M A，DE LANNOY C F. Detection of fouling on electrically conductive membranes by electrical impedance spectroscopy［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2020，242:116710.
[93]	BARBHUIYA N H，SINGH S P. Ex situ and in situ organic fouling monitoring in laser-induced graphene-based electroconductive membranes for desalination and wastewater treatment［J］. ACS Applied Nano Materials，2024，7（11）:12830-12838.
[94]	YAO L，XU X，GUI Y，et al. An electrochemical impedance spectroscopy study on ion-fouling of forward osmosis membranes［J］. Desalination，2024，578:117322.
[95]	DUTOIT M，NGABOYAMAHINA E，WIESNER M. Pairing electrochemical impedance spectroscopy with conducting membranes for the in situ characterization of membrane fouling［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2021，618:118680.
[96]	XIANG W，HAN M，DONG T，et al. Fouling dynamics of anion polyacrylamide on anion exchange membrane in electrodialysis［J］. Desalination，2021，507:115036.
[97]	AHMED F E，HILAL N，HASHAIKEH R. Electrically conductive membranes for in situ fouling detection in membrane distillation using impedance spectroscopy［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2018，556:66-72.
[98]	PINTOSSI D，SAAKES M，BORNEMAN Z，et al. Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy of a reverse electrodialysis stack:A new approach to monitoring fouling and cleaning［J］. Journal of Power Sources，2019，444:227768.
[99]	YAN B，BRISTOW N W，VOGT S J，et al. Monitoring of hollow fiber module velocity field and fouling inside individual fibers using benchtop MRI［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2021，629:119210.
[100]	YAN B，BLANKERT B，VOGT S J，et al. Monitoring residual fouling after cleaning of multi-fiber membrane modules fiber-by-fiber using non-invasive MRI monitoring［J］. Water Research，2023，229:119424.
[101]	GHASEMI S，YAN B，ZARGAR M，et al. Impact of microplastics on organic fouling of hollow fiber membranes［J］. Chemical Engineering Journal，2023，467:143320.
[102]	WYPYSEK D，WENNEMARING S，DUDIJ A，et al. Flow and fouling visualization in modules having multiple multichannel membranes［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2025，732:124205.
[103]	LIU J，WANG Y，LI Z，et al. Flux decline induced by scaling of calcium sulfate in membrane distillation:theoretical analysis on the role of different mechanisms［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2021，628:119115.
[104]	WONG P W，GUO J，KHANZADA N K，et al. In-situ 3D fouling visualization of membrane distillation treating industrial textile wastewater by optical coherence tomography imaging［J］. Water Research，2021，205:118211.
[105]	HUISMAN K T，BLANKERT B，HORN H，et al. Noninvasive monitoring of fouling in membrane processes by optical coherence tomography:A review［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2024，692:122291.
[106]	LEE S，CHO H，CHOI Y，et al. Application of optical coherence tomography（OCT）to analyze membrane fouling under intermittent operation［J］. Membranes，2023，13（4）:392.
[107]	IM S J，FORTUNATO L，JANG A. Real-time fouling monitoring and membrane autopsy analysis in forward osmosis for wastewater reuse［J］. Water Research，2021，197:117410.
[108]	IM H R，KIM C M，CHOI P J，et al. Non-destructive monitoring and prediction of fouling by organic matters and residual anionic coagulant during membrane process［J］. Chemosphere，2024，356:141778.
[109]	TANUDJAJA H J，AMIN N A，QAMAR A，et al. Precise biofilm thickness prediction in SWRO desalination from planar camera images by DNN models［J］. NPJ Clean Water，2025，8（1）:22.
[110]	DEPETRIS A，WIEDMER A，WAGNER M，et al. Automated 3D optical coherence tomography to elucidate biofilm morphogenesis over large spatial scales［J］. JoVE，2019，150:e59356.
[111]	POMPA-PERNíA A，ALEMAN A，KERST K，et al. Experimental evaluation of nanoplastics fouling behavior on ultrafiltration membranes using optical coherence tomography（OCT）［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2025，354:129520.
[112]	HUISMAN K T，FORTUNATO L，VROUWENVELDER J S，et al. A clear view of biofouling in spacer filled membrane filtration channels:Integrating OCT and CT for improved visualization and localization［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2024，697:122573.
[113]	ZHANG C，QU Y，LIU J，et al. Unraveling the role of NaCl on microfiltration fouling:insights from In situ analysis of dynamic interfacial behaviors［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2024，690:122223.
[114]	SUN W J，LAM K M，LI X Y. Effect of the shape change on the mass transport of bio-flocs in water［J］. Colloids and Surfaces A:Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects，2018，544:144-151.
[115]	MENG B Y，LI X Y. In situ visualization of concentration polarization during membrane ultrafiltration using microscopic laser-induced fluorescence［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2019，53（5）:2660-2669.
[116]	SHANG W，WANG R，DONG W，et al. Laser induced fluorescence（LIF）technique visualizes and characterizes concentration polarization and fouling layer in the cross-flow nanofiltration［J］. Separation and Purification Technology，2019，212:520-527.
[117]	CROMBEZ S，LECLERC P，RAY C，et al. Computational hyperspectral light-sheet microscopy［J］. Optics Express，2022，30（4）:4856-4866.
[118]	CHEN L，LI R，ZHANG Y，et al. In situ visualization of membrane fouling evolution during ultrafiltration using label-free hyperspectral light sheet fluorescence imaging［J］. Environmental Science& Technology，2023，57（11）:4533-4542.
[119]	CHEN L，ZHANG Y，LI R，et al. In situ visualization of combined membrane fouling behaviors using multi-color light sheet fluorescence imaging:A study with BSA and dextran mixture［J］. Journal of Membrane Science，2022，649:120111.
[120]	HONTANI Y，XIA F，XU C. Multicolor three-photon fluorescence imaging with single-wavelength excitation deep in mouse brain［J］. Science Advances，2021，7（12）:eabf3531.