Mechanisms governing the initiation and maintenance of partial nitrification from a microbial ecological perspective

ZHANG Liang; JIA Chenjie; LI Jialin

doi:10.13205/j.hjgc.202603001

Volume 44 Issue 3

Mar. 2026

Turn off MathJax

Article Contents

Article Navigation > ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING > 2026 > 44(3): 1-10

ZHANG Liang, JIA Chenjie, LI Jialin. Mechanisms governing the initiation and maintenance of partial nitrification from a microbial ecological perspective[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(3): 1-10. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202603001

Citation:

ZHANG Liang, JIA Chenjie, LI Jialin. Mechanisms governing the initiation and maintenance of partial nitrification from a microbial ecological perspective[J]. ENVIRONMENTAL ENGINEERING , 2026, 44(3): 1-10. doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202603001

Citation:

PDF( 746 KB)

Mechanisms governing the initiation and maintenance of partial nitrification from a microbial ecological perspective

doi: 10.13205/j.hjgc.202603001

1. National Engineering Laboratory for Advanced Municipal Wastewater Treatment and Reuse Technology，College of Environmental Science and Engineering，Beijing University of Technology，Beijing 100124，China

Received Date: 2026-01-09
Available Online: 2026-04-11
Publish Date: 2026-03-01

Abstract

Abstract

This study reconceptualized partial nitrification from a microbial ecological perspective by elucidating the dynamic competition between AOB and NOB across the initiation， maintenance， and destabilization phases. Continuous selection pressure was proposed as the core determinant of process stability within a community-process coupled framework. The review indicates that the initiation depends on non-steady-state disturbances that amplify AOB growth advantages， whereas the maintenance phase is characterized by a metastable state with dynamic community structure but relatively stable function， where NOB persist at low abundance or under spatial constraint. When cumulative disturbances weaken AOB competitiveness， NOB can rapidly rebound， inducing a critical shift from partial to complete nitrification. Accordingly， operational strategies centered on resource supply， niche constraint， and community feedback are outlined， emphasizing window-period management to enhance system resilience. The alignment of time-resolved community data with key operational parameters is further discussed as a basis for identifying instability thresholds and early-warning signals to support predictive control and risk management in partial nitrification processes.
- partial nitrification,
- microbial ecology,
- community succession,
- functional guild competition,
- system stability

FullText(HTML)

References(78)

References

[1]	WANG Z，ZHENG M，DUAN H，et al. A 20-year journey of partial nitritation and anammox（PN/A）：from sidestream toward mainstream[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2022，56（12）：7522-7531.
[2]	PENG Y Z，SHAO H D，YANG Y D，et al. Energy consumption analysis of municipal wastewater treatment plants based on anammox[J]. Journal of Beijing University of Technology，2015，41（4）：621. 彭永臻，邵和东，杨延栋，等. 基于厌氧氨氧化的城市污水处理厂能耗分析[J]. 北京工业大学学报，2015，41（4）：0621.
[3]	LOUCA S，POLZ M F，MAZEL F，et al. Function and functional redundancy in microbial systems[J]. Nature Ecology& Evolution，2018，2（6）：936-943.
[4]	WU L，NING D，ZHANG B，et al. Global diversity and biogeography of bacterial communities in wastewater treatment plants[J]. Nature Microbiology，2019，4（7）：1183-1195.
[5]	YANG Q，YANG Y B，YANG Z Q，et al. Effect of dissolved oxygen on shortcut nitrification stability and functional flora[J]. China Environmental Science，2018，38（9）：3328-3334. 杨庆，杨玉兵，杨忠启，等. 溶解氧对短程硝化稳定性及功能菌群的影响[J]. 中国环境科学，2018，38（9）：3328-3334.
[6]	LIU Y，NGO H H，GUO W，et al. The roles of free ammonia（FA）in biological wastewater treatment processes：A review[J]. Environment International，2019，123：10-19.
[7]	ZHOU Y，OEHMEN A，LIM M，et al. The role of nitrite and free nitrous acid（FNA）in wastewater treatment plants[J]. Water Research，2011，45（15）：4672-4682.
[8]	YANG Q，PENG Y，LIU X，et al. Nitrogen removal via nitrite from municipal wastewater at low temperatures using real-time control to optimize nitrifying communities[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2007，41（23）：8159-8164.
[9]	LI S，LI J，YANG S，et al. Rapid achieving partial nitrification in domestic wastewater：Controlling aeration time to selectively enrich ammonium oxidizing bacteria（AOB）after simultaneously eliminating AOB and nitrite oxidizing bacteria（NOB）[J]. Bioresource Technology，2021，328：124810.
[10]	BAE W，BAEK S，CHUNG J，et al. Optimal operational factors for nitrite accumulation in batch reactors[J]. Biodegradation，2001，12：359-366.
[11]	YU L，CHEN S，CHEN W，et al. Experimental investigation and mathematical modeling of the competition among the fast-growing“r-strategists” and the slow-growing“K-strategists” ammonium-oxidizing bacteria and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria in nitrification[J]. Science of the Total Environment，2020，702：135049.
[12]	SOLIMAN M，ELDYASTI A. Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacteria（AOB）：opportunities and applications—a review[J]. Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology，2018，17（2）：285-321.
[13]	MEHRANI M J，SOBOTKA D，KOWAL P，et al. The occurrence and role of Nitrospira in nitrogen removal systems[J]. Bioresource Technology，2020，303：122904.
[14]	LAURENI M，FALåS P，ROBIN O，et al. Mainstream partial nitritation and anammox：long-term process stability and effluent quality at low temperatures[J]. Water Research，2016，101：628-639.
[15]	BANNAR-MARTIN K H，KREMER C T，ERNEST S K M，et al. Integrating community assembly and biodiversity to better understand ecosystem function：the community assembly and the functioning of ecosystems（CAFE）approach[J]. Ecology Letters，2017，21（2）：167-180.
[16]	KENT T R，SUN Y，AN Z，et al. Mechanistic understanding of the NOB suppression by free ammonia inhibition in continuous flow aerobic granulation bioreactors[J]. Environment International，2019，131：105005.
[17]	CERRUTI M，GUO B，DELATOLLA R，et al. Plant-wide systems microbiology for the wastewater industry[J]. Environmental Science：Water Research& Technology，2021，7（10）：1687-1706.
[18]	TRINGE S，MERING C V，KOBAYASHI A. Comparative metagenomics of microbial communities[J]. Science，2005，308（5721）：554-557.
[19]	GAO V D，MORLEY-FLETCHER S，MACCARI S，et al. Resource competition shapes biological rhythms and promotes temporal niche differentiation in a community simulation[J]. Ecology and Evolution，2020，10（20）：11322-11334.
[20]	ZHANG B，YU Q，YAN G，et al. Seasonal bacterial community succession in four typical wastewater treatment plants：correlations between core microbes and process performance[J]. Scientific Reports，2018，8（1）：4566.
[21]	HAN M，ZHOU M，WANG H，et al. Progress in microbial ecology of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria in partial nitrification systems for wastewater treatment[J]. Microbiology China，2023，50（4）：1621-1638. 韩梦欣，周明达，汪涵，等. 污水短程硝化体系氨氧化菌与亚硝酸盐氧化菌的生态学研究进展[J]. 微生物学通报，2023，50（4）：1621-1638.
[22]	RAN X，WANG T，ZHOU M，et al. A Novel Perspective on the instability of mainstream partial nitrification：the niche differentiation of nitrifying guilds[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2025，59（18）：8922-8938.
[23]	SKOYLES A，CHAGANTI S R，MUNDLE S O，et al. Nitrification kinetics and microbial community dynamics of attached biofilm in wastewater treatment[J]. Water Science and Technology，2020，81（5）：891-905.
[24]	USHIKI N，JINNO M，FUJITANI H，et al. Nitrite oxidation kinetics of two Nitrospira strains：the quest for competition and ecological niche differentiation[J]. Journal of Bioscience and Bioengineering，2017，123（5）：581-589.
[25]	MEHRANI M-J，SOBOTKA D，KOWAL P，et al. New insights into modeling two-step nitrification in activated sludge systems–The effects of initial biomass concentrations，comammox and heterotrophic activities[J]. Science of the Total Environment，2022，848：157628.
[26]	LIU X，XIAO C，HU J，et al. Influence of nitrogen loading on the performance of partial nitrification processes and the evolution of microbial communities[J]. Geomicrobiology Journal，2024，41（5）：584-593.
[27]	ZHENG Z，HUANG S，BIAN W，et al. Enhanced nitrogen removal of the simultaneous partial nitrification，anammox and denitrification（SNAD）biofilm reactor for treating mainstream wastewater under low dissolved oxygen（DO）concentration[J]. Bioresource Technology，2019，283：213-220.
[28]	ARNALDOS M，AMERLINCK Y，REHMAN U，et al. From the affinity constant to the half-saturation index：understanding conventional modeling concepts in novel wastewater treatment processes[J]. Water Research，2015，70：458-470.
[29]	LI J，XU K，LIU T，et al. Achieving stable partial nitritation in an acidic nitrifying bioreactor[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2019，54（1）：456-463.
[30]	CARRERA J，JUBANY I，CARVALLO L，et al. Kinetic models for nitrification inhibition by ammonium and nitrite in a suspended and an immobilised biomass systems[J]. Process Biochemistry，2004，39（9）：1159-1165.
[31]	SáNCHEZ O，MARTí M C，ASPé E，et al. Nitrification rates in a saline medium at different dissolved oxygen concentrations[J]. Biotechnology Letters，2001，23（19）：1597-1602.
[32]	SCHRAMM A，de BEER D，van den HEUVEL J C，et al. Microscale distribution of populations and activities of Nitrosospira and Nitrospira spp. along a macroscale gradient in a nitrifying bioreactor：quantification by in situ hybridization and the use of microsensors[J]. Applied and Environmental Microbiology，1999，65（8）：3690-3696.
[33]	LAANBROEK H J，BODELIER P L，GERARDS S. Oxygen consumption kinetics of Nitrosomonas europaea and Nitrobacter hamburgensis grown in mixed continuous cultures at different oxygen concentrations[J]. Archives of Microbiology，1994，161（2）：156-162.
[34]	NOWKA B，DAIMS H，SPIECK E. Comparison of oxidation kinetics of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria：nitrite availability as a key factor in niche differentiation[J]. Applied and Environmental Microbiology，2015，81（2）：745-753.
[35]	BLACKBURNE R，VADIVELU V M，YUAN Z，et al. Kinetic characterisation of an enriched Nitrospira culture with comparison to Nitrobacter[J]. Water Research，2007，41（14）：3033-3042.
[36]	KIM D J，KIM S H. Effect of nitrite concentration on the distribution and competition of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria in nitratation reactor systems and their kinetic characteristics[J]. Water Research，2006，40（5）：887-894.
[37]	ZHOU W，ZHANG Q，WANG B，et al. Predicting aeration time and nitrite accumulation rate variations for Partial Nitritation：A model incorporating nitrogen oxidation rate dynamics[J]. Water Research，2025，268：122615.
[38]	TCHOBANOGLUS G，BURTON F，STENSEL H D. Wastewater engineering：treatment and reuse[J]. American Water Works Association Journal，2003，95（5）：201.
[39]	SHARIF SHOURJEH M，KOWAL P，LU X，et al. Development of strategies for AOB and NOB competition supported by mathematical modeling in terms of successful deammonification implementation for energy-efficient WWTPs[J]. Processes，2021，9（3）：562.
[40]	HELLINGA C，SCHELLEN A，MULDER J W，et al. The SHARON process：an innovative method for nitrogen removal from ammonium-rich waste water[J]. Water Science and Technology，1998，37（9）：135-142.
[41]	SCARPONI D，NAWROT R，AZZARONE M，et al. Resilient biotic response to long-term climate change in the Adriatic Sea[J]. Global Change Biology，2022，28（13）：4041-4053.
[42]	WANG Z，ZHENG M，DUAN H，et al. Acidic aerobic digestion of anaerobically-digested sludge enabled by a novel ammonia-oxidizing bacterium[J]. Water Research，2021，194：116962.
[43]	ZHOU J，FENG Y，WU X，et al. Communication leads to bacterial heterogeneous adaptation to changing conditions in partial nitrification reactor[J]. Science of the Total Environment，2024，927：172110.
[44]	QIAN W，PENG Y，LI X，et al. The inhibitory effects of free ammonia on ammonia oxidizing bacteria and nitrite oxidizing bacteria under anaerobic condition[J]. Bioresource Technology，2017，243：1247-50.
[45]	MA B，YANG L，WANG Q，et al. Inactivation and adaptation of ammonia-oxidizing bacteria and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria when exposed to free nitrous acid[J]. Bioresource Technology，2017，245：1266-1270.
[46]	ILGRANDE C，LEROY B，WATTIEZ R，et al. Metabolic and proteomic responses to salinity in synthetic nitrifying communities of Nitrosomonas spp. and Nitrobacter spp.[J]. Frontiers in Microbiology，2018（9）：2914.
[47]	SEDLACEK C，GIGUERE A，DOBIE M，et al. Transcriptomic response of Nitrosomonas europaea transitioned from ammonia-to oxygen-limited steady-state growth[J]. mSystems，2020，5（2）：e00709-19.
[48]	VILLAVERDE S，GARCIA-ENCINA P，FDZ-POLANCO F. Influence of pH over nitrifying biofilm activity in submerged biofilters[J]. Water Research，1997，31（5）：1180-1186.
[49]	PARK S，BAE W，CHUNG J，et al. Empirical model of the pH dependence of the maximum specific nitrification rate[J]. Process Biochemistry，2007，42（12）：1671-1676.
[50]	HU Z，LIU T，WANG Z，et al. Toward energy neutrality：novel wastewater treatment incorporating acidophilic ammonia oxidation[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2023，57（11）：4522-4532.
[51]	PICONE N，POL A，MESMAN R，et al. Ammonia oxidation at pH_2.5 by a new gammaproteobacterial ammonia-oxidizing bacterium[J]. The ISME Journal，2021，15（4）：1150-1164.
[52]	HUNIK J H. Engineering aspects of nitrification with immobilized cells[M]. Wageningen：Wageningen University and Research，1993.
[53]	KAELIN D，MANSER R，RIEGER L，et al. Extension of ASM3 for two-step nitrification and denitrification and its calibration and validation with batch tests and pilot scale data[J]. Water Research，2009，43（6）：1680-1692.
[54]	YU L F，MO P C，YANG X L，et al. Low-temperature adaptation strategies of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria under long-term operation[J]. China Water& Wastewater，2021，37（23）：68-72. 于莉芳，莫鹏程，杨秀玲，等. 长期运行条件下亚硝酸盐氧化菌的低温适应策略[J]. 中国给水排水，2021，37（23）：68-72.
[55]	LI J，YU D，ZHANG P. Partial nitrification in a sequencing batch reactor treating acrylic fiber wastewater[J]. Biodegradation，2013，24（3）：427-435.
[56]	LE L T，LEE S，BUI X T，et al. Suppression of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria under the combined conditions of high free ammonia and low dissolved oxygen concentrations for mainstream partial nitritation[J]. Environmental Technology& Innovation，2020，20：101135.
[57]	WANG Z，ZHENG M，XUE Y，et al. Free ammonia shock treatment eliminates nitrite-oxidizing bacterial activity for mainstream biofilm nitritation process[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal，2020，393：124682.
[58]	YU H，ZHU J，LIU Y，et al. A comprehensive review of stabilization control strategies for partial nitritation processes[J]. Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering，2025，13（5）：112698.
[59]	LI S，KANG X，ZUO Z，et al. Dynamic pH regulation drives Nitrosomonas for high-rate stable acidic partial nitritation[J]. Water Research，2024，262：121999.
[60]	MADSEN J S，SøRENSEN S J，BURMøLLE M. Bacterial social interactions and the emergence of community-intrinsic properties[J]. Current Opinion in Microbiology，2018，42：104-109.
[61]	LIU W，YANG Q，MA B，et al. Rapid achievement of nitritation using aerobic starvation[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2017，51（7）：4001-4008.
[62]	YU L，WANG Y，LI R，et al. The differential proliferation of AOB and NOB during natural nitrifier cultivation and acclimation with raw sewage as seed sludge[J]. RSC Advances，2020，10（47）：28277-28286.
[63]	ZHOU Z，QI M，WANG H. Achieving partial nitrification via intermittent aeration in SBR and short-term effects of different C/N ratios on reactor performance and microbial community structure[J]. Water，2020，12（12）：3485.
[64]	WANG T，LI X，DAN Q，et al. Unraveling rapid start-up and stable maintenance of partial nitrification in domestic wastewater under high dissolved oxygen[J]. Bioresource Technology，2025，418：131989.
[65]	BISWAS R，BAGCHI S，BIHARIYA P，et al. Stability and microbial community structure of a partial nitrifying fixed-film bioreactor in long run[J]. Bioresource Technology，2011，102（3）：2487-2494.
[66]	HOU Y，ZHAO R，MA J，et al. Sludge enrichment and intermittent gradient aeration：Modulating microbial communities for start-up of partial nitrification in a sequencing batch reactor（SBR）[J]. Bioresource Technology，2025，418：131916.
[67]	PATHAK S，WANG S，JANKA E. Achieving partial nitritation in anammox start-up environment[J]. Water，2022，14（2）：229.
[68]	DUAN C，ZHANG Q，LI J，et al. Partial nitrification response to dissolved oxygen variation and aerobic starvation：Kinetics and microbial community analyses[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal，2024，481：148621.
[69]	ZHAO B H，YANG H S，LI Y Q，et al. Achieving partial nitrification in a continuous-flow bioreactor by free ammonia treatment combined with low dissolved oxygen[J]. Biochemical Engineering Journal，2024，203：109194.
[70]	CUI Y，GAO J，WU Z，et al. Inhibition of Nitrospira and Nitrotoga by paracetamol achieved the rapid start-up and long-term stable operation of partial nitrification for low-strength ammonium wastewater[J]. Chemical Engineering Journal，2023，454：140139.
[71]	XIAO K，TANG R，WEI J，et al. Achieving stable partial nitrification through synergistic inhibition of free ammonia and salinity on nitrite-oxidizing bacteria[J]. Frontiers of Environmental Science& Engineering，2025，19（4）：42.
[72]	GILBERT E M，AGRAWAL S，BRUNNER F，et al. Response of different Nitrospira species to anoxic periods depends on operational DO[J]. Environmental Science& Technology，2014，48（5）：2934-2941.
[73]	JIA C，LI J，LI Z，et al. Influence of high-load shocks on achieving mainstream partial nitrification：Microbial community succession[J]. Water Research X，2025，27.
[74]	HAUSHERR D，NIEDERDORFER R，BüRGMANN H，et al. Successful year-round mainstream partial nitritation anammox：assessment of effluent quality，performance and N₂O emissions[J]. Water Research X，2022，16：100145.
[75]	CHEN Y，SANJAYA E H，GUO G，et al. High nitrogen removal performance of anaerobically treated fish processing wastewater by one-stage partial nitritation and anammox process with hydroxyapatite（HAP）-based syntrophic granules and granule structure[J]. Bioresource Technology，2021，338：125526.
[76]	MEERBURG F A，VLAEMINCK S E，ROUME H，et al. High-rate activated sludge communities have a distinctly different structure compared to low-rate sludge communities，and are less sensitive towards environmental and operational variables[J]. Water Research，2016，100：137-145.
[77]	CUI B，YANG Q，LIU X，et al. The effect of dissolved oxygen concentration on long-term stability of partial nitrification process[J]. Journal of Environmental Sciences，2020，90：343-351.
[78]	JIANG C，XU S，WANG R，et al. Comprehensive assessment of free nitrous acid-based technology to establish partial nitrification[J]. Environmental Science：Water Research& Technology，2018，4（12）：2113-2124.